
NoW
‘Siren: Survive the Island’ – Women’s Desires, Competition, and Solidarity
This Week’s Show, Music, and Film
2023.06.16
Credit
Article. Kim Rieun, Na Wonyoung (Music Critic), Im Sooyeon (CINE21 Reporter)
Design. Jeon Yurim
Photo Credit. Netflix
Siren: Survive the Island (Netflix)
Kim Ri Eun: In the Netflix survival show Siren: Survive the Island, six groups of women professionals—soldiers, police, firefighters, stunt performers, bodyguards, and athletes—team up by profession to compete and claim bases. While smashing the window or having strenuous physical battles to conquer the base may highlight the physical stamina of women, there are also fierce mind games such as negotiating alliance with other teams on the spot or spying for information. They also apply their professional knowledge, like Team Soldier using feathersticks to light a big fire or Jung Min-seon of Team Firefighter explaining how you can put out fire depending on the direction of the hose. In short, Siren: Survive the Island shows how women in fields that used to be considered physically disadvantageous for them could solve challenges with different skills.
Kim Ri Eun: In the Netflix survival show Siren: Survive the Island, six groups of women professionals—soldiers, police, firefighters, stunt performers, bodyguards, and athletes—team up by profession to compete and claim bases. While smashing the window or having strenuous physical battles to conquer the base may highlight the physical stamina of women, there are also fierce mind games such as negotiating alliance with other teams on the spot or spying for information. They also apply their professional knowledge, like Team Soldier using feathersticks to light a big fire or Jung Min-seon of Team Firefighter explaining how you can put out fire depending on the direction of the hose. In short, Siren: Survive the Island shows how women in fields that used to be considered physically disadvantageous for them could solve challenges with different skills.
Reality competition shows that limit contestants by gender could sometimes be a device that reinforces stereotypes. But Siren: Survive the Island reveals each contestant’s multidimensional character by allowing them to make various choices in extreme situations, not only through competition but also through teamwork, alliance, and strategy. That’s why it also features some moving or fun scenes like Jung Min-seon trying to split wood all by herself on a team mission of firewood-chopping after Kim Hyeon-ah, the leader of Team Firefighter gets injured; or Team Firefighter and Team Athlete, once allies, having a base battle and saying things like, "At last, I’m fighting against you, unnie,” or shouting, "This feels great!” Contestants sometimes struggle to survive by badmouthing or trying to take advantage of the other team, but they all work towards fair play, like how Team Soldiers admitted to having violated the rules during the battle because they had gotten too emotional. Siren: Survive the Island keeps the director's perspective to a minimum and focuses on actual interviews by the cast and captions based on their comments, which paradoxically, seems to present a fantasy that is hard to see in the era of neo-liberalism. Women, who used to be considered relatively weaker beings, not only showcase their physical capabilities but also maintain their humanity, solidarity, and collaboration even in an infinitely competitive setting that pushes everyone to their limits. If physical reality entertainment with contestants competing unconditionally based on physique is the trend of 2023, then Siren: Survive the Island could serve as the barometer that shows us what values are still essential in our society in this era.
“Salad Days” by iiso
Na Wonyoung (Music Critic): Following “Banana Shake,” which re-emerged as a meme on short-form video platforms last year, another hit song by Humming Urban Stereo, “Salad Day,” was timely summoned to iiso's “Salad Days.” In this track, which sampled keyboard sounds from the original song, copied the overall chord progression and "sped it up" within the video length rather than considering the aesthetics of the remix, there are many elements that are mutually compatible—not only from 2005 to 2023, but also from 2023 back to 2005.
Na Wonyoung (Music Critic): Following “Banana Shake,” which re-emerged as a meme on short-form video platforms last year, another hit song by Humming Urban Stereo, “Salad Day,” was timely summoned to iiso's “Salad Days.” In this track, which sampled keyboard sounds from the original song, copied the overall chord progression and "sped it up" within the video length rather than considering the aesthetics of the remix, there are many elements that are mutually compatible—not only from 2005 to 2023, but also from 2023 back to 2005.
There are two features that stand out: the 2-step garage and drum and bass elements that emphasized the rattling snare and hi-hat over kick; and the vocal styles of Yozoh and iiso, often employing subdued and soft melodic singing. With such similarities, the two tracks feel harmonious even across slightly different time periods. This is because while electronic dance music had always been transplanted into Korean pop music with some time difference, clear singing have provided stabilization and some room to for the art of electronica to infiltrate seamlessly. Styles that originated from the underground dance floors of 1990s Britain and delivered the vivid power of divisive rhythms are no exception. Korean electronic music teams of the 2000s, composed of skilled producers, DJs, and fantastic vocals (sometimes through guest geatures) used this form to successfully create an alternative yet popular dance music. Since the 2010s, such legacy became either embedded in the production process of idol pop or, as in the case of iiso, fit into individual musician's toolbox; However, this influence has diminished or become less relevantdue to stronger autonomy and specialization of electronic musicians. In this context, the sampling of “Salad Days” opens the backdoor to the youthful, fresh days of electronic pop music for some time. These fragmented moments of the times, which have been cut off as tiny trend pieces, cross the threshold and flow, riding along and interacting with the power that remains in the beats.
Elemental
Im Sooyeon (CINE21 Reporter): Element City, where different elements such as fire, water, land, and air live together. Ember, the element of fire, lives with her parents who run a grocery store. She rarely leaves Fire Town and is most likely to inherit the store unless something were to happen. Ember's peaceful days get interrupted by Wade, the element of water and a city inspector, who visits the shop to point out multiple violations and orders it to be closed. The two characters, who seemed like they would never mix because they’re the complete opposites, get to know each other, and eventually fall in love. As a project that started from the personal life of Director Peter Sohn, a second-generation Korean-American, class dynamics surrounding the diaspora are reflected throughout the movie. In particular, the fact that Ember is depicted as an outsider who breaks away from the mainstream and faces discrimination while Wade is an upper-class elite makes the audience take the metaphor more intuitively. The film honestly delivers the message that being different can create conflict, but it can also be the first step to change, by using the rules of romance and family drama. Moreover, the imaginative character design and animation techniques that translate the chemical properties of elements to visuals and movements make the universal story more special. Elemental is a new animated film by Pixar Animation Studios, the maker of Inside Out and Soul.
Im Sooyeon (CINE21 Reporter): Element City, where different elements such as fire, water, land, and air live together. Ember, the element of fire, lives with her parents who run a grocery store. She rarely leaves Fire Town and is most likely to inherit the store unless something were to happen. Ember's peaceful days get interrupted by Wade, the element of water and a city inspector, who visits the shop to point out multiple violations and orders it to be closed. The two characters, who seemed like they would never mix because they’re the complete opposites, get to know each other, and eventually fall in love. As a project that started from the personal life of Director Peter Sohn, a second-generation Korean-American, class dynamics surrounding the diaspora are reflected throughout the movie. In particular, the fact that Ember is depicted as an outsider who breaks away from the mainstream and faces discrimination while Wade is an upper-class elite makes the audience take the metaphor more intuitively. The film honestly delivers the message that being different can create conflict, but it can also be the first step to change, by using the rules of romance and family drama. Moreover, the imaginative character design and animation techniques that translate the chemical properties of elements to visuals and movements make the universal story more special. Elemental is a new animated film by Pixar Animation Studios, the maker of Inside Out and Soul.
Copyright © Weverse Magazine. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized reproduction and distribution prohibited.
Unauthorized reproduction and distribution prohibited.