REVIEW
Miracles come at a painful cost in ‘Madoka Magica’
The film ‘Walpurgisnacht: Rising’ confronts the paradox of sacrifice and salvation
Credit
ArticleLee Jayeon(“CINE 21” Reporter, Culture Critic)
Photo CreditLOTTE CINEMA

An ordinary girl develops special powers and saves the world from evil—the magical girl genre has kept that promise for a long time. That is, until “Puella Magi Madoka Magica” arrived in 2011 and flipped the premise on its head to look at the underbelly. Every wish-fulfilling miracle comes at a chilling cost, and the same girls who save the world end up becoming monsters that have to be destroyed. Magic starts to look more like a contract than a blessing, and hope is reduced to little more than an asset for the taking. The old premise that magical girls save the world ends up raising a new question: Who saves the girls while they’re out saving the world?

Marking the series’ 15th anniversary, the fourth film, “Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie: Walpurgisnacht: Rising,” raises a similar question again. Ever since Homura Akemi rewrote the order of the universe to protect Madoka Kaname in 2013’s “Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie: Rebellion,” the girls’ fates have once more been hanging in a precarious balance. You don’t have to memorize every last bit of the series’ tangled lore. What’s important is that you understand how the world “Madoka Magica” has spent years building actually works. The violence these girls endure takes several forms—a contract that trades in miracles, a classification system that turns victims into monsters, and salvation that seals another person’s fate in the name of love. Those three acts of violence are the pillars of the “Madoka Magica” world’s central tragedy, and they’re also a guide for understanding “Walpurgisnacht: Rising.”

Picking up the miracle tab
One day, a mysterious creature named Kyubey appears before ordinary middle schooler Madoka with an offer: become a magic girl and fight witches, and have one wish granted in exchange. In most magical girl stories, transforming is about realizing your potential, but in “Madoka Magica,” it’s to fulfill a contractual obligation. The wish the girls choose is entirely up to them, but no one properly explains to them exactly what it will cost them. It’s a deal that demands you sign on without ever having the risks explained to you. The side that drew up the terms of the deal walks away free of responsibility, while the girls alone bear the consequences. This promise of freedom where the buck gets passed down to the individual feels an awful lot like our own modern world where it’s everyone for themselves, acting at their own risk.

What makes this world even more chilling is that all the hope and despair the girls experience gets converted into energy. To counter the universe’s entropy, Kyubey harvests the energy released when a magical girl turns into a witch. This may be a magical girl story, but in this particular tale, pain isn’t fodder for personal growth. Instead, it’s a resource to be recycled. The more ardent the wish, the more energy is released when things flip to despair. In other words, the miracles these girls dream of come with a price tag. Hope is paid up front and despair billed later in an endless cycle. What makes “Madoka Magica” so brutal isn’t the girls’ misfortune alone but how it’s required fuel to keep an efficiency-obsessed world running.

Interestingly, “Walpurgisnacht: Rising” introduces a new idea that echoes Kyubey’s offer: rumors of a Lizard Phone, said to grant wishes in exchange for fighting curses. Homura uses the device to rally girls into battle against Wraiths. Meanwhile, a strange incident unfolds in Mitakihara—a girl without a Soul Gem is hunting Wraiths. The terms of the contract and the conditions that define magical girls have begun to falter. Even so, the old bargain hasn’t changed: fight, and you get your wish. Kyubey’s contract once drew girls into a world order built on sacrifice. Now Homura, who remade the world to save Madoka, is the one overseeing things. You can change the exploitative intermediary, but it does nothing to change the fact that the whole system runs on exploitation.

Hero today, monster tomorrow
In the “Madoka Magica” world, once a magical girl falls into total despair, she becomes a witch, her final form. Sayaka Miki, who signed her contract to heal a boy’s hand, ends up a witch too. The orchestra and sheet music in her Labyrinth are traces of what had been her desire to help her crush play music again. The unfulfilled feelings of the girl that monster once was live on on that twisted stage, and this grotesque premise complicates the distinction between hero and monster. A girl who saves the world is a hero, but once her hope dries up, she’s seen as a threat in need of elimination. Her sacrifice and good intentions are erased, the danger she poses the only thing remaining. Perhaps it could be said that the magical girls are pointing their weapons at their own futures. You can take out one witch, but you won’t change the way of the world that makes witches in the first place. What brings this tragedy to life so vividly is the distinctive visual language of “Madoka Magica.” The cute characters are fated to come up against the witches’ Labyrinths, collages of paper cutouts and eerie decor.

But “Walpurgisnacht: Rising” turns this long-standing conflict on its head. Later on in the film, Madoka embraces a nameless girl who appears on Walpurgis Night in an act of recognizing the being that remains inside an enemy witch instead of defeating and eliminating her. If the music left behind in Sayaka’s Labyrinth bore witness to the traces of humanity in the monster, this embrace represents a conscious decision not to turn away from them. Madoka looks past the monster’s exterior at the pain that lingers on and tries to save her by taking that pain in her arms. Here, old ideas about fighting that are a staple of the genre are filled with new possibilities. The heroic act of striking down evil returns as an ethical practice of trying to understand someone else’s suffering.

Limits on love in the name of salvation
In order to save Madoka, Homura relives the same span of time over and over. She watches Madoka die, and (in one of many timelines) when Madoka begs to be killed before she turns into a witch, Homura takes Madoka’s life with her own hands by destroying her Soul Gem. For Homura, who has to carry the weight of that memory with her, love was a fight against death from the start. Madoka, meanwhile, sacrifices herself by wishing for the total extinction of witchkind before they can even be born into existence. As a result, she ceases to be human and instead becomes the Law of the Cycle. In this world where everyone else has been saved, Madoka’s life disappears. In “Rebellion,” Homura refuses to accept that ending. She separates Madoka from the Law of the Cycle, becomes a Demon, and remakes the world. Madoka sacrificed herself for everyone else—Homura rewrote the world for one person. Their love for each other gives way to opposite ethical quagmires. On one side stands the well-established trope where self-sacrifice is a given for saving others. On the other, the controlling nature of wanting to decide the fate of the one you love for them.

In “Walpurgisnacht: Rising,” Madoka rejects the memories Homura has rewritten and tries to return to the Law of the Cycle. To Homura, it’s a sacrifice she has to stop at all costs, but to Madoka, it’s a decision she’s made for herself. The moment you believe you know better than someone else what will make them happy, the line between devotion and domination inevitably blurs. So when someone you love chooses to sacrifice themselves, do you have the right to take away their right to choose in the name of protecting them? The weight of the loss Homura has endured makes her actions understandable, but that desperation doesn’t justify every outcome.

The shift in who’s saving whom, from Homura to Madoka, leaves the film’s audience to sit with this question. If you simply swap the two roles, is it enough to dismantle the structure of sacrifice? If the power to decide the fate of someone else’s life for them is still there, salvation can really just be putting a new coat of paint on old ideas of dominance. What “Madoka Magica” has spent the past 15 years exploring isn’t so much the power of magic as the ethics of salvation. Sacrificing one person for the world or sacrificing the world for one person—both choices fall short. The enemy these girls must ultimately face goes beyond the witches and monsters they fight—it’s a world that makes sacrifice a precondition for miracles, along with the arrogance of trying to decide someone’s fate for them, even in the name of love.

Copyright ⓒ Weverse Magazine. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction and distribution prohibited